Young people often think that they have already communicated their distress through their behaviour or by ‘testing out’ a response from a professional by only telling them part of their story. This is part of the help-seeking behaviour that children develop from infancy. It is crucial that professionals respond to this help-seeking behaviour, and especially where it raises safeguarding concerns.
Where young people ‘test out’ the response of professionals, by telling them part of their experiences or something that is concerning them, professionals should follow this up with the young person by asking questions that give them agency, such as:
What would you like help with?
What would you like to happen now that you have told me this?
Stop and think; analyse the information shared by the child with professionals who know the child and family, and if you believe that the child may be at risk of significant harm, make a referral to children’s social care. Never say you will keep information that the child has shared confidential but do assure them that you will help them to be safe.
You should also go back to the young person once safeguarding action has been taken to ask them whether this was the response they were hoping for, or if they hoped for something different.
This was highlighted within the Dorset LCSPR report ‘The Siblings’ (August 2022). This review reinforces the fact that anyone who works with children and young people should be able to respond effectively if a young person says that they have been sexually abused , or ‘tests out’ the professional’s response by sharing some of their concerns or worries, or by displaying behaviour which could indicate that they are being sexually abused.
Further learning can be found from this helpful Summary of risk factors for improved practice around harmful sexual behaviour, learning from case reviews.
What are the signs and indicators?
In Plymouth all agencies have committed to use the CSA Centre Signs and Indicators template.
Click here to access the templateThe signs of child abuse are not always obvious, and some signs on their own may not indicate that a child is being sexually abused, and so it is often about professionals being able to build up a cumulative picture of their concerns. Professionals should also build a picture of signs and indicators of a suspected perpetrator of child sexual abuse. The CSA Centre also provides Typology of child sexual abuse offending focussing on the contexts offering guidance on Sexual abuse which takes place within family environments often remains hidden and is the most secretive and difficult type of abuse for children and young people to disclose. It may be particularly difficult to disclose abuse by a sibling.
Many children and young people do not recognise themselves as victims of sexual abuse – a child may not understand what is happening and may not even understand that it is wrong especially as the perpetrator will seek to reduce the risk of disclosure by threatening them, telling them they will not be believed or holding them responsible for their own abuse.
Where sexual abuse is being perpetrated on one or more family members, it may be possible to identify by patterns of referrals or presentations to different agencies in their local community over time. There may be a range of signs, but any one sign doesn’t necessarily mean that a child is being sexually abused; however, the presence of number of signs should indicate that you need to consider the potential for abuse and consult with others who know the child to see whether they also have concerns.
Signs to look for
Signs of CSA can include:
Unexplained changes in behaviour, including becoming more fearful, aggressive, withdrawn, clingy;
Problems in school, difficulty concentrating, appearing distracted and distant or dissociated, drop off in academic performance.
Becoming uncharacteristically aggressive
Poor bond or relationship with a parent/care giver
Running away or going missing
Always choosing to wear clothes which cover their body
Refusing to wash and bathe or bathing excessively
Sleep problems, nightmares or regressed behaviours i.e. bed wetting;
Frightened of or seeking to avoid spending time with a particular person
Knowledge of sexual behaviour/language that seems inappropriate for their age
Physical symptoms including pregnancy in adolescents where the identity of the father is vague or secret, STIs, discharge or unexplained bleeding
Poor hygiene, which often leads to social isolation in school
Injuries and bruises on parts of the body where other explanations are not available especially bruises, bite marks or other injuries to breasts, buttocks, lower abdomen or thighs and near genitals
Injuries to the mouth, which may be noted by dental practitioners.
Other Factors
Other factors may include:
Frequent house moves
Attempts to disguise injuries or attribute them to other causes
Failure to register with a GP
Frequent absences from school
Failure to cooperate with agencies or to let police, children’s social care or other agencies into the home, or letting children be seen alone by professionals
Isolation of children (and other members) within the family from practitioners, and the wider community
A child or young person who self-harms, misuses drugs, alcohol or solvents, and/or develops mental health problems
Domestic abuse within the family heightens the risk and there is growing understanding on links between domestic abuse and children displaying harmful sexual behaviour
Repeated pregnancies with no evidence of a father
Genetic abnormalities in pregnancy or in children who are born
Impacts of CSA
Finkelhor and Browne, (1986) describe four likely impacts of CSA:
• Traumatic sexualization (where sexuality, sexual feelings and attitudes may develop inappropriately)
• A sense of betrayal (because of harm caused by someone the child vitally depended upon)
• A sense of powerlessness (because the child’s will is constantly contravened)
• Stigmatisation (where shame or guilt may be reinforced and become part of the child’s self-image)
The Centre of Expertise on Child Sexual Abuse highlights the impact that secrecy (including the fear and isolation this creates) and confusion (because the child is involved in behaviour that feels wrong but has been instigated by trusted adults) has on the child. While these impacts are not unique to Child Sexual Abuse in the Family Environment, their combination and intensity in the context that they take place makes the experience particularly damaging.
Key messages from research on identifying and responding to disclosures of CSAIn the long-term people who have been sexually abused are more likely to suffer with depression, anxiety, eating disorders and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). They are also more likely to self-harm, become involved in criminal behaviour, misuse drugs and alcohol, and to commit suicide as young adults.
These signs do not necessarily mean that a child is being abused, there could be other things happening in their life which are affecting their behaviour, so it is important we provide children with opportunities to talk about their home life. You should obtain a good understanding of relationships the child has with those that are in the home, who visit, or they visit regularly or people who might look after them or they stay with. To assess the behaviours and understand the level of risk to a child or young person you can utilise the Understanding harmful sexual behaviour/Hackett continuum.
These tool helps practitioners assess what would be deemed to be healthy sexual development and would need to be considered against children’s developmental and cultural milestones. It is important to stress that these tools should be used to inform professional decision-making, rather than determine it.
Although as practitioners it might seem obvious to us that it is never the child’s fault they were sexually abused, it is important to reiterate this with the child, and explain that they are not in trouble. For some children who have been groomed it is likely the perpetrator will have told them that it was because they (the child) wanted the abuse to happen, or that their family/non abusing parent will not believe them, or it is their fault, all of this is often compounded with confusion and shame. All these issues will impact on children telling a professional or trusted adult about the abuse they are experiencing and will be important to remember when supporting a child who you believe may have been sexually abused or has told you that they have been. There are practice considerations/guidance issued further on in the toolkit for those working with children who tell a professional that they have been abused and then later say that nothing happened, which may be another effect of grooming.
60 Second Reflection
72% of young people we surveyed in Plymouth would tell someone if they had concerns about sexual abuse. But, help-seeking appears to be context dependent, with fewer young people saying they would speak out in situations where peers were involved.
A non-judgemental, trusting, and open relationship facilitates young people seeking advice and support about abuse.
A lack of confidentiality, blaming, burden of proof and the unknown consequences of disclosing would prevent young people from seeking help.
Our findings emphasise the deep-seated beliefs of young people that they will be judged for sexual abuse they may suffer and are likely to experience negative consequences if they disclose abuse. It is essential that steps are taken to educate adults in how to sympathetically respond to concerns or disclosures, and address these negative beliefs held by young people to ensure they feel safe, empowered, and supported to seek help.